{
  "schema_version": "restricted-presentation-review-1",
  "date": "2026-10-19",
  "standard": "restricted-frozen-portfolio-review-1",
  "status": "complete",
  "certified_blind": false,
  "human_research": false,
  "assets": {
    "web/assets/app.js": "c491c606923238ac79c24280f49d5f1331ca765078f3133bf0dc6dc704837978",
    "web/assets/app.css": "0d57c7d61d0bca74a6d74ffe7f8d0683f55d444fd974c610bb41f5793ced01c6",
    "web/case-study.html": "3f31976e02b13662c41b129c551085714ca9411b10b71291652237c587a0b6a9"
  },
  "evidence_files": {
    "governance/review-2026-10-19/browser-checks.json": "9384516ae477d393750d2f9fc9d1c95239305bb933ae09b73efc01dc2d50e6e6",
    "governance/review-2026-10-19/changed-content-checks.json": "aa788196f0a14e1f640ecf68ea2c0089d0a4da2d23364fa19266bd97b3d73ded",
    "governance/review-2026-10-19/follow-up-reader.json": "b8033ad540d040b1dd97a3e68c73556044215edb6e7854e366e0a8efb6c927e9",
    "governance/review-2026-10-19/follow-up-return.md": "7f7631cee85e9ea8133db3770d2ed06b463784dfacae6dbaa9b3846d1442590d",
    "governance/review-2026-10-19/follow-up-first-return.md": "720bc56a33adbee6eb96dd4502d66f9e85222b263014a285c8a22cc80733c57c",
    "governance/review-2026-10-19/follow-up-first-reader.json": "f23ed00866855dc924f84bd0721ae177a1bf9ffbd3da023f1834897b39ea82aa",
    "governance/panel/r1-13e/context-audit.json": "3db75d5266e61daea258d4cd539d143d55826ce136b8f3b7175d831d2ce406d2",
    "governance/panel/r1-13e/dispositions.json": "95bb35f89f891a31d37605189b071b7e48c8ddefd472dbcf27b831a0a7ed657a",
    "governance/panel/r1-13e/pre-panel-notes.md": "509bd2e13f25d5974d0e02f58059ae574ab6650f8cc689ef660e4b568492f31f",
    "governance/panel/r1-13e/reader-plan.json": "ac312be79e92d8257f0cd8ce79a29c1b90eaf3bb52bde17db3bc824ff65808a5",
    "governance/panel/r1-13e/packet/manifest.json": "60150924256673b8d882d73f2f1a6a43c2d870e94821651af2cc53fec6ca0bf2",
    "governance/review-2026-10-19/chart-checklist.md": "bc84796593930acff01065b2957f41a8425ec065a50c04282fa7f025c0d570d4",
    "governance/renders/default-320.png": "79f2ce13ebaabfb2a0ec2068daa732660bffd0bdf3c335443ebf169438bdc9fe",
    "governance/renders/default-588.png": "7f812c9bedb0e581ea621ce4474a077333322aa95c7b62b5bd08be3c710bfa0c",
    "governance/renders/default-589.png": "cf5a089b3c216b6e9fd9f0e0b9392d394bc32be6f3616311d07ec2a3ad9b6e46",
    "governance/renders/default-599.png": "4d99d4e18ab1ddf975fcc6469f6b9901c7d62541155ce108d1c3d1687de1c24a",
    "governance/renders/default-601.png": "4db3735fa6fe8785b5c4658a712aba0d8249e7644b7de9ac56da0a61d7f259c2",
    "governance/renders/default-719.png": "5e6f26256887db1f3fb3d9c7ea9e030e9cdb8b6e1bb176e9946fa6c0bd0949c5",
    "governance/renders/default-721.png": "a1d18f079a5fa8a6b96804e37e6c36ba81d773fd7c0910c90e1187a82c6c779b",
    "governance/renders/default-767.png": "1dac574c063a53bed444b9c86a667e1ac367a743f98ccaead1eba8b6d5bd51c4",
    "governance/renders/default-769.png": "c853822f3512e8367458d157e612cff9faebef063353ccf37223de16c3d6fc88",
    "governance/renders/default-899.png": "f4f914df4f5ee4848bec5b67b37b4a3c633eacc02ccc22ae1b213c94e8ce43c9",
    "governance/renders/default-901.png": "c65582f7549838c76f8b274ec3f62d7f5154dbdb7cd1f26306e7eedd2e0ff40c",
    "governance/renders/default-1280.png": "398763037ef7cbdaf830ad417184477db48c1b164cc07781e134acb42e9def4f",
    "governance/renders/filtered-pc-320.png": "caed7154793c196b9ef0e3fa2c058873b72314c7cdcfb4df84474ec47508c715",
    "governance/renders/filtered-pc-1280.png": "7c8d4d6163f5c6530dbc74f3f2bcd51f03980a5d686893b88adffb4218f8a767",
    "governance/renders/single-c06-320.png": "cf8a8ada8b9872ce0a82bf7d8ae9753b17ca971e4a1b904873d582622f34f7e5",
    "governance/renders/single-c06-1280.png": "a761113a07f17fcb1ec5e03076c3d2685212ca34024b7af06402c30bb6c2ca54",
    "governance/renders/empty-audit-c01-320.png": "375e99bce0437f8b2eb16430c992287c9e665777ff70c216f1641c4557b937c0",
    "governance/renders/empty-audit-c01-1280.png": "e9a1b3ee6bfd2ecc7f9ff4f2d694eb2a8fb00a556e773f33b301397fa0ff9bf4",
    "governance/renders/known-then-1280.png": "cd0b73e3366b6f73a0ed3fd01f0e9c4beb086ad347b98cb2f6d10a9b3e458036",
    "governance/renders/subperiod-sp2-1280.png": "85876ebdb561dad0424c0a1a2bf6dcc7eb13aa38067418d728a6c91a0623e969",
    "governance/renders/record-demo01-320.png": "52e696978ef396a0cc9275e533198c9098dc94433460c3dfe8c2114afd4992e9",
    "governance/renders/record-demo01-1280.png": "3f3ad5c67b46b0b34108d3debe645f5fddbb9f720691ee38e7c386f63f708f05",
    "governance/renders/definitions-320.png": "4d53edeedc15f6413f543d7cc50cb694521d8adb7f71f424e11d7aa3fba73e1e",
    "governance/renders/definitions-1280.png": "6145210c2223c35e6dde13ff3ab18c9cad0518221459ba148f2f10425c1ab3a9"
  },
  "checks": [
    {
      "id": "chart_geometry",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "V02 uses descending horizontal bars, a zero baseline and one exact linear scale. Rank labels, visible values and emphasis agree with the published cells."
    },
    {
      "id": "title_and_precision",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "The dynamic title states the leading explanation without an exact long count. Plot labels use at most three significant figures; exact values stay in readouts, tables, accessible labels and exports."
    },
    {
      "id": "chart_provenance",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "Four-part frozen source/as-of/flags/view strip, explicit denominator, rule-order and designed-mix disclosure. Minimum 12 px resolves conflicting typography clauses under the standard meta-rule."
    },
    {
      "id": "responsive_states",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "24 actual renders; 12 widths including 320 and 1280 and viewport 588/589 around the 520 px chart-host branch. Default, P-C, single C06, empty readiness, known-then, SP2, record and definitions reached."
    },
    {
      "id": "pointer_readouts",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "Current browser execution covers fine hover and real coarse tap, reloaded contexts, negative host-top position, viewport bounds and above-point fallback; no synthetic empty M02 population."
    },
    {
      "id": "table_and_keyboard",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "Current keyboard/focus/export interaction checks pass; a real table and exact readouts supplement rounded plot labels. No exhaustive accessibility certification."
    },
    {
      "id": "reader_method",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "Four fresh simulated processes, three domain roles and one chart reader. Prompts and image assignments committed before seating; complete returns, no observable tool/action events. Same service/workstation, no certified blindness."
    },
    {
      "id": "finding_dispositions",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "17 pooled findings: 6 fixed, 8 accepted with explicit source/scope/tradeoff reasons, 3 rejected with reasons, zero open actionable defects."
    },
    {
      "id": "changed_content_recheck",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "Browser checks at 320/1280 plus a separate image-only simulated follow-up read confirm current guidance and scope wording. Directed verification after fixes is not a second naive panel."
    },
    {
      "id": "honest_scope_disclosure",
      "status": "pass",
      "evidence": "Current applicable tests and N/A reasons are separate from historical outcomes. Six historical misses and ten unrepresented classes remain disclosed. No independent final-control effectiveness or human usability claim; public readback required at publication."
    }
  ],
  "nonapplicable": [
    {
      "requirement": "Certified-blind process, complete provider request-body audit and independently held reader custody",
      "reason": "No such certification is claimed. Method completion is supported by actual frozen prompts, separate-process returns, observed no-tool events, dispositions and rechecks."
    },
    {
      "requirement": "Empty M02 chart population",
      "reason": "All 120 supported states are nonempty, minimum 465. Empty readiness is exercised separately. No values changed to fabricate a chart empty state."
    },
    {
      "requirement": "Human-population usability or final-control detection effectiveness",
      "reason": "Not established or claimed by this restricted presentation review."
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Four separate model processes, not four human or independently held evaluators.",
    "One shared model service/workstation. Full provider-request and hidden-system-context audit not established.",
    "Prompts and images frozen before returns. At most three concurrent processes; fourth queued automatically.",
    "Domain images show expanded information sections, not only the collapsed initial viewport. Browser checks separately cover interactive behavior.",
    "Completed method and dispositions do not certify absence of every possible misunderstanding."
  ],
  "publication_authorized": false
}